Mr. Chitlik

Revenue Management

Can Any Hotel Sale Really be Used as a 'Comparable'?

By David Chitlik, Vice President, Atlus Hospitality Tax Group

A hotel is not the same as a house or a warehouse or an apartment or office building, and assessors often don't understand why. The hospitality sector is frequently the most challenging part of a jurisdiction's property tax base. The only way to derive a hotel's real property value from a purchase price is for an assessor to spend time and energy understanding the adjustments needed to accurately determine what part of that purchase price relates to real property and whether or not it can be used as a sales comparable for other hotels in that jurisdiction.

Too few assessors are willing to make this effort. They are more likely to look at sales of nearby hotels just like they would home sales. They are either unwilling to investigate, or indifferent to, underlying factors that determine overall sales prices. It's easy for the assessor to believe that if a full-service hotel sold for $300,000 a room, then every full-service hotel in the area should be valued at $300,000 per room.

Not necessarily. In fact, that is not likely true at all. A hotel sale typically includes several elements that make it unique in the market. Those elements should pose questions that assessors need to answer to help make adjustments before a sale can be deemed reliable for use in a comparability analysis. Some of those questions should include:

  1. Was the hotel sold as part of a portfolio transaction?

    That's been the case for most sales over the past decade or so. But if the portfolio included hotels in New York, Boston, Washington, Los Angeles, San Francisco and other higher-priced destinations, it's not likely it can be used to accurately determine room values in Chesapeake, Va., or Macon, Ga. Without talking to the seller and/or buyer, it's unlikely assessors will understand adjustments needed in using the portfolio hotel sale to set the value of other hospitality properties in the area.

  2. Was the hotel sold to a Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT)?

    REITS are established to take advantage of favorable tax treatment, and that advantage drives property transactions. REIT buyers frequently will pay a premium to churn sales that can earn tax-advantaged profits. Without adjusting the purchase price of the REIT sale being used as a comparable, it clearly is not going to yield reliable market data - unless the property being assessed is also being offered for sale to a REIT.

  3. Who bought the hotel?

    Foreign investors approach U.S. property differently than American buyers. International investors tend to be more patient and eye a longer return. They may be satisfied with a 2 percent annual rate over 30-50 years and frequently will pay more for stability of income. A U.S. investor tends to look for a 7-to-10 year holding period, demands a higher return and tries to negotiate a lower going-in price. Without divining business culture's impact on a sales price, the assessor is not going to understand its relevance for comparable sales purposes.

  4. Did the hotel sale include a management contract with a recognized flag in place?

    It may well be that a branded hotel such as a Marriott or Ritz-Carlton garners more value than another brand, but an assessment is supposed to reflect the land, bricks-and-mortar only. The premium one might pay for the manager's brand advertising, reservations system and rewards program is not part of the real property and adjustments should be made.

  5. Was the sales price driven by the hotel's bar and restaurant business? This was not an issue when bar and restaurant sales were largely a function of room service. Often, a hotelier was happy to break even, or perhaps make a little positive revenue, on food and drink.

    Now, with a focus on meetings and conventions, bar and restaurant sales can be major profit centers, adding significantly to hotel gross revenue. But, again, the assessor is dealing with bricks and mortar and land, so bar and restaurant influences on value may have to be adjusted out of a hotel's purchase price for tax purposes, and out of the sales price of a hotel being used as a comparable.

  6. Was location a primary factor in determining purchase price? Premiums are often paid to get into markets with high barriers to entry, such as Las Vegas, San Francisco, and, until recently, New York City. If it is difficult to build from the ground up due to lack of open land or onerous permitting processes, owners are willing to pay more for an existing hotel.

While receiving an assessment based on poorly adjusted sales is not a good situation for the hotel property owner, there is potentially a worse scenario if an appeal is filed. A hotelier who challenges the assessment, and goes into an appeals board hearing armed with his or her facts about the subject property, can be ambushed. Remember, the board works under the belief that the assessment is already correct, so the appellant has to prove the assessor erred. After making the claim and presenting the evidence, the hotel owner can be confronted by someone from the assessor's office defending the assessment with a sheaf of papers reflecting unadjusted sales of "comparable" hotels. This happens more often than you might think.

What can be done to avoid this situation? The appellant either has to really know the comparable properties being used to support the subject assessment, or he or she needs to hire a consultant who does. It's imperative to have information such as location, brand, ancillary businesses and amenities, as well as any other data on the local hotels to counter an unadjusted sale offered as a comparable.

There are data services that can help with this data collection, but remember, assessors and appeals boards often have access to the same sources. It's best for the owner or consultant to get out and survey the market situation regarding other hotels.

In summary, assessing a hotel properly is difficult, but it can be done if assessors are willing to do their homework. But if an assessor isn't willing, the hotelier - or the consultant - has to be able to demonstrate the correct real property value to an appeals board. Eliminating excess tax expense depends on getting it right. Don't let the process go without education for the accessor and, if necessary, challenge to the assessment.

David J. Chitlik, CAE, has extensive experience in all facets of the property tax assessment and appeal industry. Prior to joining Altus Group, he spent 18 years as the Director, then Senior Director, of the Property Tax Department at Marriott International. Initially he oversaw a staff of more than 20 associates working on both sales and property tax compliance, appeals and audits. Mr. Chitlik has many years of property tax consulting experience as well, first with Tenenbaum Hill & Associates, Inc. and then Marvin F. Poer & Company. He was the Managing Director for the Mid-Atlantic Regional Office for both companies with a combined 11 years with both firms. Mr. Chitlik can be contacted at david.chitlik@altusgroup.com Please visit http://www.altusgroup.com/ for more information. Extended Bio...

HotelExecutive.com retains the copyright to the articles published in the Hotel Business Review. Articles cannot be republished without prior written consent by HotelExecutive.com.

Receive our daily newsletter with the latest breaking news and hotel management best practices.
Hotel Business Review on Facebook
RESOURCE CENTER - SEARCH ARCHIVES
General Search:

FEBRUARY: Social Media: Interacting with the Hotel Customer

Nisha Thakkar

While social media has become a mainstream marketing channel, there are many variables that hoteliers are not taking advantage of to increase their revenue. Unlike other mainstream marketing avenues, social media is not static, as platforms continuously find ways to increase engagement with both users and advertisers. As social platforms have realized their massive marketing opportunities within their user base, they have increasingly capitalized on their clearly defined users by providing advertisers access to them. Today, the popularity of social channels has created a “pay-to-play” model that leaves many business owners and managers perplexed as to which channels to focus on, and the right budget to allocate in order to maximize return on investment (ROI). READ MORE

Cass Bailey

These days, a lot goes into choosing the perfect hotel. Hotel choice no longer depends solely on the location, price, and amenities; it depends on experience. Customers have become more interested in experiential features instead of whether or not the hotel has a five-star review. As the phrase goes, many “do it for the gram.” When looking to book their stay, the Instagram generation is interested in things that are eye-catching and worthy of sharing with their followers. Just searching the hashtag “wanderlust” reveals millions of images of different travel experiences from around the world. READ MORE

Tim Sullivan

As hoteliers’ key audiences spend less time on the Web and more time on their smartphones’ social apps, it is crucial for hotels to have a digital engagement strategy that creates meaningful interactions on social channels. Desktop still converts higher, but the path to a booking is a journey full of touch points across social. Now that social media platforms are maturing, hotels can go beyond targeting their own guests to discovering new profitable audiences. They can reach and drive sales for all sides of the business: leisure, corporate and group sales. However, before hoteliers think about social engagement, they need to cover the basics of personalization and one-to-one marketing. READ MORE

Chris Teso

Social media has traditionally been approached as a marketing tool for top-of-funnel activities. However, the activities associated with generating awareness, like creating viral posts and taking advantage of real-time marketing moments, are difficult to measure and even harder to link to real business value. Yet, marketers innately know that social media has real opportunity as their audience is there—in volume and in frequency. As a result, a new trend is emerging among hotel marketers that takes distinct advantage of the direct follower model of social networks: the marriage of the loyalty program with social media marketing. READ MORE

Coming Up In The March Online Hotel Business Review




Feature Focus
Human Resources: Inspiring a Journey of Success
In an increasingly competitive environment where hotels are competing to attract, and more importantly, to keep top talent, Human Resource managers are realizing the need to focus on improving their Employee Experience. Smart managers are embracing the idea of Employee Wellness which translates into a system of physical, mental, emotional, and purposeful well-being. Some organizations are even providing free counseling for their employees and their dependents. The goal is to nurture, support and engage with their employees in a way that increases productivity, improves customer service, enhances loyalty, and creates a more harmonious work environment for all. Along with this development is the need for more effective, ongoing training. Many HR managers rely on external training firms for this, but there is a growing trend which taps the experience and expertise that already exists within the organization. For example, younger employees likely have greater knowledge of social media which an older generation might struggle with. Harnessing this peer-to-peer learning can be an efficient and cost effective way of increasing skills, and as a result, the knowledge transferred is likely to be more acceptable and relevant. Finally, HR managers need to foster an environment that empowers people and taps into their full potential, inspiring a personal journey of success. The March Hotel Business Review will take a look at some of the strategies and techniques that human resource directors are currently developing in order to achieve success.