Mr. Jost

Guest Service / Customer Experience Mgmt

Building a Culture of Feedback and Turning Reviews into Insights

By Benjamin Jost, Co-founder & CEO, TrustYou

Every hotel manager has a fear that wakes him or her up in the middle of the night in a cold sweat. It isn't a standard fear that most people have; hotel leaders aren't in the throes of the dream where they showed up to a presentation naked. This particular fear has to do with the ink that's being spilled on the internet. It's the fear of a negative review on a major review site or social network.

To put context around the world we live in today, there are more than 3 million hotel reviews written each week. That's 18,000 reviews per hour. Needless to say, not all of them will be from guests who loved every moment of their stay.

Whether it was an employee having a bad day, a cleaning crew that hadn't gotten through their daily routine quickly enough, or something completely outside a hotel manager's control (guests who had an airline lose their luggage may not be in a terrific mood at arrival), the chances of a negative review popping up online are actually pretty good. It's how hotels handle things from there that will separate the wheat from the chaff.

Engaging With Guests on Their Own Territory

Smart hotel leadership today has come to realize that reviews are going to be written online, no matter what. And they've also come to realize that most customers who write a negative review might actually be asking for help, as opposed to engaging in some sort of virtual shaming.

In many cases, hotels that are willing to respond to guest concerns will find that their guests are willing to listen. And in many cases, they are willing to give a property another chance.

It's never easy to apologize, especially in a public setting, but this very action can have immensely positive results. In addition to the guest who is being responded to, others will see that the hotel is being responsive. Research shows that 95% of hotel bookings are informed by reviews from other customers. At the very least, making a good faith effort to address concerns will show other potential guests that a hotel is interested in trying to create a great stay.

Drawing Actionable Insights

Rather than placing their heads in the sand, or treating hotel reviews as a simple customer service channel, hotel leaders need to see online feedback as an opportunity to learn about the guest experience they are providing. If a review mentions that there is an issue with room cleanliness, then leadership should investigate why this might be the case.

In the days before the internet, when people gathered together and talked about an experience they had at a hotel, the property would never have any insight into the discussion. That's not the case anymore.

By creating a running tally of feedback, hotels now have the ability to identify trends across their guest experience. Is cleanliness continually being knocked? If so, maybe it is time to change leadership on the cleaning crew. Is a particular chef always on the clock when guests offer incredible praise for the property's restaurant? If so, maybe management should take steps to focus on retaining that employee.

One of the major initiatives that seems to permeate across industries today is using all of the data an organization has at their disposal to identify actionable insights; using information to make smarter decisions. Hotels that consider reviews to be another form of data can capitalize on information provided from first hand sources, and will inevitably improve their guest experience.

Changing the Culture Around Reviews

Improved guest satisfaction is perhaps the most obvious benefit of a culture that embraces feedback. Before addressing other benefits, let's first discuss what a "culture of guest feedback" means. At the top level, hotel leaders need to make a few commitments:

  • A team must be identified that can respond to feedback. In many cases, this might mean hiring a set of resources (or an external resource), or it could be adding responsibilities to current team members. In either approach, the industry best practice is to build a cross-function group consisting of someone in marketing, a couple of folks in customer service, someone in hotel operations and possibly someone in the legal department. Marketing teams should be able to promote achievements from hotel team members (internally and externally), while customer service should be able to address guest concerns. Having a resource (or resources) on the front lines of hotel ops can help everyone understand whether feedback is fair or unwarranted (if, for example, a guest complains that a hotel's smoking area is too far away from the building, perhaps someone in operations can explain that it's there because of state law at a particular hotel). Finally, having someone on the legal team as a soundboard to make sure that promoting positive reviews and responses from customers is done in a manner which is consistent with all regulations is important.

  • A Service Level Agreement (SLA) that identifies how long it should take for teams to respond to feedback is the second commitment from hotel leadership. Just like call center operations, SLA's can be built around the severity of a review (particularly negative guest feedback needs to be responded to upon receipt, whereas maybe it is OK if it takes up to an hour to promote positive feedback). Once SLAs are established, it becomes critical to track and make sure that all feedback is being addressed within the agreed upon timeframe. The only way to understand the impact from a culture of feedback is to track the steps to build that culture.

  • Putting a tracking methodology and/or tool in place is critical to making the culture of feedback run smoothly. This means tracking against the SLAs, but also having an understanding of what information is coming in through feedback. It is impossible to draw actionable insights without seeing the entire picture. There are many tools available that hotels can put in place to help them understand feedback, which range in price, usability and complexity.

Going beyond actionable insights, and looking past the short term, hotels that embrace a culture of feedback can anticipate dramatic increases in overall revenue. This manifests in a variety of ways. The most obvious is the increase in revenue that results from return business; guests who enjoy their experience are likely to come back. Other benefits include increases in direct bookings, which increase revenue by limiting commissions that need to be paid out. Another increase in revenue comes from the way people search for hotels. Again, 95% of bookings are informed by other guest reviews and 76% of travelers are willing to pay more for a hotel with higher reviews . (for all quotes with numbers we should provide the source as a footnote, what do you think?)

The legacy idea of hotel leadership waking up to check their rankings on any number of ratings services are coming to an end, as smart hotels embrace the idea that guest feedback can drive improvements to the guest experience and meaningful increases to the bottom line. Individual properties and international chains alike can take advantage of today's technology and their leadership can sleep better, too.

Benjamin Jost is co-founder and chief executive officer of TrustYou. Benjamin is an expert on social semantic search and is leading the big data revolution in hospitality. Prior to TrustYou, he spearheaded the Southern European M&A team for one of the world’s leading renewable energy providers and oversaw hundreds of investment cases covering a profusion of renewable technologies. He started his career in venture capital at Siemens Venture Capital and Xange Capital. Mr. Jost holds a MsC in engineering from the University of Technology in Munich and conducted research at the ENST Paris and the University of Washington Business School, Seattle. Mr. Jost can be contacted at 011 49 176 83074860 or Extended Bio... retains the copyright to the articles published in the Hotel Business Review. Articles cannot be republished without prior written consent by

Receive our daily newsletter with the latest breaking news and hotel management best practices.
Hotel Business Review on Facebook
General Search:

FEBRUARY: Social Media: Interacting with the Hotel Customer

Nisha Thakkar

While social media has become a mainstream marketing channel, there are many variables that hoteliers are not taking advantage of to increase their revenue. Unlike other mainstream marketing avenues, social media is not static, as platforms continuously find ways to increase engagement with both users and advertisers. As social platforms have realized their massive marketing opportunities within their user base, they have increasingly capitalized on their clearly defined users by providing advertisers access to them. Today, the popularity of social channels has created a “pay-to-play” model that leaves many business owners and managers perplexed as to which channels to focus on, and the right budget to allocate in order to maximize return on investment (ROI). READ MORE

Cass Bailey

These days, a lot goes into choosing the perfect hotel. Hotel choice no longer depends solely on the location, price, and amenities; it depends on experience. Customers have become more interested in experiential features instead of whether or not the hotel has a five-star review. As the phrase goes, many “do it for the gram.” When looking to book their stay, the Instagram generation is interested in things that are eye-catching and worthy of sharing with their followers. Just searching the hashtag “wanderlust” reveals millions of images of different travel experiences from around the world. READ MORE

Tim Sullivan

As hoteliers’ key audiences spend less time on the Web and more time on their smartphones’ social apps, it is crucial for hotels to have a digital engagement strategy that creates meaningful interactions on social channels. Desktop still converts higher, but the path to a booking is a journey full of touch points across social. Now that social media platforms are maturing, hotels can go beyond targeting their own guests to discovering new profitable audiences. They can reach and drive sales for all sides of the business: leisure, corporate and group sales. However, before hoteliers think about social engagement, they need to cover the basics of personalization and one-to-one marketing. READ MORE

Chris Teso

Social media has traditionally been approached as a marketing tool for top-of-funnel activities. However, the activities associated with generating awareness, like creating viral posts and taking advantage of real-time marketing moments, are difficult to measure and even harder to link to real business value. Yet, marketers innately know that social media has real opportunity as their audience is there—in volume and in frequency. As a result, a new trend is emerging among hotel marketers that takes distinct advantage of the direct follower model of social networks: the marriage of the loyalty program with social media marketing. READ MORE

Coming Up In The March Online Hotel Business Review

Feature Focus
Human Resources: Inspiring a Journey of Success
In an increasingly competitive environment where hotels are competing to attract, and more importantly, to keep top talent, Human Resource managers are realizing the need to focus on improving their Employee Experience. Smart managers are embracing the idea of Employee Wellness which translates into a system of physical, mental, emotional, and purposeful well-being. Some organizations are even providing free counseling for their employees and their dependents. The goal is to nurture, support and engage with their employees in a way that increases productivity, improves customer service, enhances loyalty, and creates a more harmonious work environment for all. Along with this development is the need for more effective, ongoing training. Many HR managers rely on external training firms for this, but there is a growing trend which taps the experience and expertise that already exists within the organization. For example, younger employees likely have greater knowledge of social media which an older generation might struggle with. Harnessing this peer-to-peer learning can be an efficient and cost effective way of increasing skills, and as a result, the knowledge transferred is likely to be more acceptable and relevant. Finally, HR managers need to foster an environment that empowers people and taps into their full potential, inspiring a personal journey of success. The March Hotel Business Review will take a look at some of the strategies and techniques that human resource directors are currently developing in order to achieve success.