Ms. Nedry

Mobile Technology

Technology Trauma May Cause Guests to Need the ER-Emotional Recovery

By Roberta Nedry, President and Founder, Hospitality Excellence, Inc.

Please press "1" if you are frustrated, please press "2" if you are annoyed and please press "3" if you just want to SCREAM about technology replacing human resources and decision making!!!

According to Professor Stephen Hawking, one of today's pre-eminent scientists, when asked about the progression and greater impact of technology, he recently told the BBC, "The development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race." He continued with, "Humans, who are limited by slow biological evolution, couldn't compete and would be superseded." Yikes, could our hospitality leaders and employees actually be superseded?

Professor Hawking's potential forecast may seem dramatic, questionable or at least a very distant possibility to some. Yet, the issue of today's tremendous innovations and applications of technology in so many arenas, including hospitality is; how are the humans who direct, support or manage that technology doing when all does not go smoothly and how are they using their "biology" to do things the computers and software can NOT do?

How many times are hospitality and business leaders and their teams alienating loyal guests and potential customers due to a disconnect between technology solutions and human interactions? With exciting technologies emerging in all areas of hospitality and business daily, how are hoteliers preparing, managing and training their teams to ensure the personal touch is not lost Are the humans and technology performing as a team or two separate roles? How are they ensuring that reactions, responses and emotions do not also become automated for guests and especially that their employees are not all superseded by machines? And, when technology does cause some form of trauma, how well are employees trained to send guests to the ER and deliver an emotional recovery?

The Answer: Mobilize and train human beings to come to the rescue!

As technology continues to inspire new ways to interact and support guest preferences and needs, so should the humans behind that technology continue to inspire and reinforce ways to interact and support guest preferences and needs to complement and enhance not compete or disengage with that technology.

After staying in a well-known flagged hotel in the Northwest United States several times and being one of their loyalty club members, I thought making my next reservation would be painless, easy and welcome based on my history and desire to return again. I called the hotel directly, hoping to make that personal connection about my return visit and spoke to a front desk agent in that specific hotel. I thought for sure I would be in their system and the computer would pull me up as a familiar friend. However, when that front desk agent heard the word "reservation", she immediately transferred me to the "central reservations" center and I quickly lost the personal connection I had specifically called to make. It was late at night and the call agent I was transferred to seemed aloof and disinterested in my history. She asked for my loyalty number, as proof that I was really loyal; looking up my name and history was not enough. I felt like I was starting over and having to prove I had stayed at this property several times before and that I had been loyal to the brand. Technology that should have showcased my fabulous loyalty ended up being an impediment to making my glorious return and ended up annoying me due to the questioning and duration of the phone call. The human being using that technology was NOT trained to come to my rescue and pick up where technology left off.

I was traumatized by the experience and wished I had someone or someTHING to make me "feel" like I was welcome to come back to this property!

alt text
Photo by Brence Platner

Another study sponsored by Cornell University and authored by Dr. Rohit Verma, Dr. Spring H. Han and Lilia Karimi titled "Personalizing Guest Experience through Technology", and featured in an International Luxury Hotel Association (ILHA) luxury hotel industry trend whitepaper, talked about different kinds of technologies and how they are being used to enhance guest satisfaction and engagement.

Their study noted that "regardless of hoteliers' ability to keep pace, customers are beginning to expect these services and providers must be aware of their capabilities and their costs in order to ensure they make the appropriate choices for their establishments." Dr. Verma said that customer preferences will continue to evolve and that a 60-year-old man or a 16-year-old girl could easily have the same preferences in technology. What is interesting about those conclusions is that technology preferences may start to align with different age groups and be used more frequently on all levels but guest reactions and questions as they interact with and respond to those technologies will STILL need the humans!!!!

Some hotels have moved toward those preferences by eliminating the humans in favor of technology, such as with check in, entertainment and cuisine choices and travel arrangements. In some properties, the most people intensive position, the concierge, has been eliminated. However, Dr. Verma said even though customers are trending towards self-serve kiosks and online check- in " customer desire for a traditional, human concierge is by no means in danger of becoming obsolete." Customer desire will remain and real humans, not machines, handle desire better! Humans use language, intuition and emotion to add the personal touch to all the technology. Artificial intelligence is just that--Artificial! Use people to make the AUTHENTIC difference and perceptual intelligence!

I had placed an order for a product with a major retailer and realized I had provided the wrong address. I called back less than 12 hours later to fix my mistake. The order had not been processed yet and work had not yet begun on fulfillment. I spoke to someone in customer service to explain I simply needed to change the address. I was told that was NOT POSSIBLE! Incredulous, I responded that is was NOT possible that it was NOT possible to change the address.

I was told once again, they could not go into the system to fix the address, even though the order was not processed or underway yet. I asked for a supervisor who confirmed that they could NOT go into the system to change the address. I could not believe it. Something so simple, an easy fix and there was NO WAY to go in and change the address for an order that I would now not receive due to the faulty address. The ONLY solution was to try to intercept it after it was actually shipped which would cost the retailer more dollars and cost me greater inconvenience and delay in delivery. Technology was in charge and I was traumatized once again. I was emotionally distraught and no human being was able to come to offer any recovery. How could this be? Isn't the technology there to support customer service, not disrupt or block it? What technology systems are in place in your environments and are human beings "still allowed" to interact with them when needed and especially when guests need to go to this article's "ER", Emotional Recovery?

After this incredibly frustrating outcome, the last thing the customer service representative asked me was, 'Is there anything else I can help you with?' AAAARRRGGGHHHHHH! I was not helped and did not want anything else!!!!! I just wanted my problem solved and someone to care that it was. What is the blend between an efficient system of software and processing and adapting to the human beings delivering and receiving the services or products of that system? What kind of responses or behaviors should the humans use when frustrations or problems occur? What, if any emotions are or should be involved and how can the "ER", Emotional Recovery, be deployed when technology trauma occurs?

In the case above, employees were trained to follow a script to support the technology and phone calls, down to the final comment, which was like pouring salt into the wound. They were not trained to handle recovery or disruptions to the regular flow of service and procedures. They seemed trained on saying certain things in each call and did not know how to pay attention to the things "not" being said. When someone is upset, as in the above situation, closing the call with an empathetic statement like " I apologize for this inconvenience and we will do our best to provide a solution for you" with a corresponding tone versus a cheery, happy closing like above that seems to disregard the emotions at hand would seem to be key to employee training.

In hospitality and any industry, consider the many new technologies and systems that could have a situation happen like above, where a guest requests something that is not routine or that is part of the technology protocol.

Then what? With today's greater emphasis on more personalized experiences and more focus on individual needs, how are the soft skills of service being integrated with the exciting hard technologies being designed to improve and enhance guest and customer experiences? How are behaviors changing or how should they change as this rush of new communications, social media, software programs, reservations systems and more penetrates the industry?

In another story, a guest was on a call with an airline needing to get an assigned seat changed for his companion on a different record. The caller was an 'elite' mileage club member - his companion was not - so that seat was technically unavailable to her unless she was on the same record -- a seemingly obvious technical issue a human should be able to override, especially since the companion was the guest's wife.

As the guest tried to get the seat situation resolved, the original agent said,"Sir, that's not possible, the computer will not let us do that -- even though the seat is empty and you have the right to change her seat to be next to you". At this point the guest replied- "so the computer is in charge?" The agent's response, "YES!"

Ultimately a supervisor was able to override the system and secure the available seat for the guest's wife but until that happened, the original agent remained surprised that the guest had made the request and probably still has no idea that it was actually possible for a human to override the computer. This technology created rule was steadfast for that employee and no matter what emotions or needs his customer had at that time, the computer was in charge according to him and he had no other way to deal with the guest's frustration and request. The guest had to solve his own problem and ask for a supervisor.

Before Professor Hawking's comments start to become more realistic, consider preparing your teams for Emotional Recovery in case Technology Trauma occurs.

  1. Take a closer look at your existing technologies and then take time to evaluate the humans involved. Do they understand the full impact and opportunities and can they adapt as needs develop or be able to adapt the technology to serve guest needs and interests?

  2. Comments like: "Once it is in the system it cannot be changed," which I heard recently in another transaction, positively. Make sure employees know how to adapt or rescue a guest need when "the system" will not cooperate.

  3. Online interactions and email communications are increasing with social media and less face time. That does not mean they should sacrifice personal contact and impact in favor of efficiency and automated responses or scripts. In a customer service survey our firm recently performed for one of our clients, their customers stated they appreciated the efficiency of the immediate email responses. They did NOT appreciate or favor the automated nature of those responses and the lack of a more personalized communication.

  4. As people move to more social media resources and doing things on line, they STILL may need to make phone calls as follow up and will have questions. In another recent reservation call, I was kept on the line while the agent slowly typed in my information and kept waiting for the next screen. She was silent as she typed and so was I. No communication and no interaction. Just phone space and a clicking sound. Train your teams to make and keep a personal connection as these personal connection opportunities become more rare.

  5. Thank your guests and remember them and make sure the technology/human team understands that expressing gratitude never goes out of style. After a recent stay at a La Quinta Inn and Suites in Macon, Georgia, General Manager Dianna Self sent what may have been a form letter but it felt so personal and was immediately after my stay. Her note asked if all okay (very important ER stuff!), gave me her personal line for feedback, thanked me and invited me back again. Her note made me feel good!

Be wary of artificial intelligence, which replaces authentic human interaction. Ensure they are a team! Inspire wonderful guest experiences along with new technologies and innovations by training employees to rush guests to the ER-Emotional Recovery when needed. There are only seconds to save service moment 'lives'. Operate with emotional efficiency and create even healthier guest loyalty and bottom lines!

Roberta Nedry is President and Founder of Hospitality Excellence, Inc. and has spent over 32 years exploring, delivering and managing guest and customer experiences and service training. She helps organizations to reach levels of exceptional service and regularly consults with executives and managers on transforming customer experiences. Her Hospitality Excellence Team is internationally recognized for its expertise in creating customer experience strategies that zero in on and inspire the DNA of each client yielding enhanced internal employee experiences and external customer and brand value. Ms. Nedry’s diverse background with both public and private companies allows clients to draw on her extensive career experience for business solutions. Ms. Nedry can be contacted at 877-436-3307 or roberta@hospitalityexcellence.com Extended Bio...

HotelExecutive.com retains the copyright to the articles published in the Hotel Business Review. Articles cannot be republished without prior written consent by HotelExecutive.com.

Receive our daily newsletter with the latest breaking news and hotel management best practices.
Hotel Business Review on Facebook
RESOURCE CENTER - SEARCH ARCHIVES
General Search:

MARCH: Human Resources: Inspiring a Journey of Success

Sandy Asch

Baby boomers, Gen Xers, and especially Millennials, who now make up more than 50 percent of the workforce, want a sense of purpose at work. It’s clear that today’s workforce is increasingly concerned with doing good. People are tired of just showing up every day to perform a job. They want lasting fulfillment at home and at work. In his book, Drive, Daniel H. Pink suggests that we are in a time where individual desire to have a positive impact in the world often ranks higher than pay scale when selecting a job. Millennials, in particular, want to feel like their work has real purpose, and they want to be home for dinner. READ MORE

Whitney Martin

As new properties explode on the scene and traveler choices abound, hotels know they have to pull out all the stops to make every guest experience a positive one. Are staff friendly are courteous? Are rooms clean? Are meals excellent? Are bills accurate? We rely on our employees to execute their jobs, not just correctly, but with enthusiasm. And, if they don’t, business suffers. We do our best to hire good people (in a competitive market), we give them a little training, and then we HOPE they create raving fans. Ever heard the expression “hope is not a strategy”? READ MORE

Joyce Gioia

Worldwide, the hospitality industry is going through a transformation. In response to workforce shortages, many employers have looked for---and found---ways to reduce staff by using automation. Despite this trend, there are continuing shortages of skilled workers from front line housekeepers to general managers. Hospitality leaders are looking for and finding innovative ways to find the talent. This article will give you an overview of what’s working for general managers and their human resource professionals to find the people they need to staff their properties. READ MORE

Paul Feeney

A recent report from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, showed that close to 3 million people voluntarily quit their jobs a couple of years ago, a 17% increase from the previous year, proving that opportunities for employees are abundant and we have shifted back to a candidate-driven marketplace. Why is this important? Employee retention should always be of utmost importance, but requires awareness as to why employees leave to begin with. Numerous statistics show that the #1 reason people quit their jobs is a disconnect or poor relationship with their boss or immediate supervisor or manager. This shows that turnover of staff is mostly a manager issue. READ MORE

Coming Up In The April Online Hotel Business Review




Feature Focus
Guest Service: The Personalized Experience
In the not-too-distant future, when guests arrive at a hotel, they will check themselves in using a kiosk in the lobby, by- passing a stop at the front desk. When they call room service to order food, it will be from a hotel mobile tablet, practically eliminating any contact with friendly service people. Though these inevitable developments will likely result in delivered to their door by a robot. When they visit a restaurant, their orders will be placed and the bill will be paid some staff reduction, there is a silver lining – all the remaining hotel staff can be laser-focused on providing guests with the best possible service available. And for most guests, that means being the beneficiary of a personalized experience from the hotel. According to a recent Yahoo survey, 78 percent of hotel guests expressed a desire for some kind of personalization. They are seeking services that not only make them feel welcomed, but valued, and cause them to feel good about themselves. Hotels must strive to establish an emotional bond with their guests, the kind of bond that creates guest loyalty and brings them back time and again. But providing personalized service is more than knowing your guests by name. It’s leaving a bottle of wine in the room of a couple celebrating their anniversary, or knowing which guest enjoys having a fresh cup of coffee brought to their room as part of a wake-up call. It’s the small, thoughtful, personal gestures that matter most and produce the greatest effect. The April issue of the Hotel Business Review will document what some leading hotels are doing to cultivate and manage guest satisfaction in their operations.