Dr. McGuire

Revenue Management

Building a Strategic Analytic Culture in Hospitality

By Kelly McGuire, Vice President, Advanced Analytics, Wyndham Destination Network

Hospitality executives struggle to find the balance between delivering a guest experience that fosters loyalty and repeat business, and delivering on their revenue and profit responsibilities to stakeholders, shareholders or franchisors. If you invest too much in the guest experience, you could impact profits, but if you focus on too many cost cutting measures to drive profits, you can negatively impact the guest experience.

Decisions made in one department of a hotel can have impacts across the organization (a marketing program that puts too much pressure on operations to deliver, or a labor savings initiative that creates long lines, for example). Analytics can help restore balance, ensuring that each department plays a well-defined strategic role in contributing to the balance of guest experience and profitability. This only works if the organization as a whole is committed to this kind of analytically based, strategic decision making.

Strategic Analytic Culture

So, what does a strategic analytic culture (SAC) look like? The figure below outlines the interrelated components of a SAC.

alt text
Figure 1: Strategic Analytic Culture Framework

A strategic analytic culture starts and ends with executive management commitment. This level of support is required to make the necessary investments in people, process and technology, as well as to ensure the alignment among departments that is critical to enterprise-level thinking. The executive management team uses analytics to set business strategy. Rather than being guided by individual intuition or aspiration, the data and analytics offer a fact-based pathway towards the strategy, which is based on market conditions, customer characteristics and company's operating circumstances. The foundation of any analytics program is an organization-wide commitment to information management.

Information management programs include data governance to provide data definitions and guidelines for storing and accessing information; data integration to ensure that data from disparate systems is matched and consolidated; data quality programs to ensure data is cleansed before use in analytics; and data storage infrastructure that facilitates access for analytics and reporting. An all-encompassing information management strategy facilitates enterprise use of analytics. Most organizations have isolated pockets of analytic capability, whether it be in revenue management, marketing or finance. Enterprise use of analytics brings these silo-ed departments together, ensuring that decision making is not done in isolation.

Mark Lomanno, Executive Board Member at newBrandAnalytics, in a recent interview for the SAS/Center for Hospitality Research blog, "The Analytic Hospitality Executive", sees the role of analytics increasing in hospitality. "Traditionally the role of analytics has been more in the financial metrics measurement category, to some degrees in the operations category, and in the marketing category; however, in the future all those will come together," Mark said. He predicted that over time, online hotel reviews and comments in social media will replace traditional guest (patron, passenger) satisfaction measures as the primary gauge of customer satisfaction, and that companies will be able to start predicting occupancy and rates by the quality and nature of the hotel's consumer comments and reviews. "This will force operations and marketing to work very closely together to react very quickly to what the consumer is saying," Mark said.

Mark's forecast for the industry points to the need to break down silos, improve communication and synchronize decision making. When the entire enterprise is aligned around analytics, it creates a culture of fact-based decision making. You've probably heard the saying, "In God We Trust, All Others Must Bring Data". Companies with a SAC back up all of their decisions with data and analytics, rather than instinct and persuasion. This doesn't mean that you stifle creativity. It means that creative thought is supported by an analysis to back up conclusions or reinforce decision making. In fact, strategic use of analytics can help organizations become more creative and more agile, when it helps to uncover insights that were not apparent on the surface.

Ted Teng, President, CEO at The Leading Hotels of the World provided this perspective in a recent video interview for SAS and the Cornell Center for Hospitality Research: "We are an industry of emotional decisions. We badly need analytics and good data for us to make the right decisions." Ted explained that the hospitality market has completely changed and industry operators can longer rely on how they did things 20 years ago. "There's a lot of talk about big data out there. I'd be happy with just small data - some data - that allows us to make better decisions that are based on facts rather than based on our emotions."

Where is your organization in this cycle? Are you getting stuck at executive commitment? Perhaps it's been too difficult to build an information management infrastructure? Is analytic competency still residing in pockets across the organization? For the rest of this paper, we'll talk about how you move your organization towards the vision outlined in the strategic analytic culture diagram.

Focus Areas for a Strategic Analytic Culture(1)

Moving your organization in towards a strategic analytic culture requires more than just investments in analytic technology. Building a SAC starts with people, process, organization and technology, in three focus areas within your organization.

  • Business Analytics Skills and Resources
  • Information Environment and Infrastructure
  • Internal Analytic Processes

Focus Area 1: Business Analytics Skills and Resources

1. Find the right balance of resources - Building a strategic analytic culture is not simply hiring a bunch of analytic modelers, but rather striking the balance between analytic rigor and business application. Your best revenue managers understand their markets and their bu-siness, sometimes even better than they understand the forecasting and optimization algorithms underlying the revenue management system. It is their ability to interpret the analytic results and apply them to their market that makes them successful. Think about how to achieve this across the organization with business acumen supported by analytic rigor.

2. Make analytics more approachable - Analytical skills are in short supply. In fact, in the US it is estimated that demand for deep analytical resources will be 50% higher than the supply by 2018 (Sources: US Bureau of Labor Statistics, US Census, Dun & Bradstreet: company interviews, McKinsey Global Institute analysis). Organizations will need to figure out a way to make analytics more approachable. Highly visual, wizard-driven tools enable non-technical users to explore and share "aha moments" without having to be PhD statisticians. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, and that's true in analytics as well. Graphics are much easier for executives to consume quickly and will help to foster that commitment to fact-based decision making. Enabling business users to create and share insights will further the mission of enterprise use of analytics, while free the limited supply of analytical resources to focus on the more rigorous analysis.

Focus Area 2: Information Environment and Infrastructure

Without a strong foundation of reliable and accurate data, analytic results will be suspect, and buy-in becomes impossible. You can spend all meeting arguing about whether RevPAR should include the out of service rooms, or spend it making strategic decisions about price position relative to the competitive set. A sound information management strategy gets you on the road to analytic success, and away from the need to confirm and reconfirm the data. Here's how to establish the foundation for a commitment to information management:

1. Establish a data governance discipline - As data and analytics become centralized, data governance ensures consistency in data definitions, data integration guideline, and data access rules. This is crucial to establishing "single version of the truth" in results and reporting, as well as to build a sustainable process for continuing to advance organizational data collection.

2. Upgrade your information architecture - In order to effectively leverage the insights trapped in today's fast moving, diverse, volumes of data, you need a modern data infrastructure that can support enterprise-class analytics and dynamic visualizations.

3. Bridge the gap between IT and the Business - A strong partnership between IT and the business must be fostered to ensure that the infrastructure described above facilitates exploration and fact based decision making. A key new resource to add to the organization may need to be the "translator" between IT and the business - someone who understands how to interpret the business requirements into an IT context.

4. Capitalize on advanced analytics, not reporting - Earlier this year, I described the importance of advanced analytics like forecasting and optimization, to help organizations become more proactive in decision making. Any SAC relies on forward looking analysis to say ahead of trends and identify opportunities in advance.

Focus Area 3: Internal Processes

Enterprise use of analytics is not as simple as "everyone log in and go." With limited personnel and technology resources, organizations will need processes in place to ensure access to critical analytical or IT resources. Then, the organization can better identify, prioritize and address analytical requirements - whether it be deploying a new retention model or investing in a new analytical tool.

1. Manage analytics as an ongoing process, not a one off project - Internal processes must be designed around sustainable, long term analytic performance throughout the analytics lifecycle. You will need to think not just about developing models, but deploying them, embedding them into a business process, and monitoring and improving them over time.

2. Facilitate Collaboration - Traditionally, hospitality, like so many other industries, has operated with silo-ed departments. To facilitate collaboration, the silos that prevent collaboration must be removed. Technology may be the glue that binds departments together, but true collaboration will require realigning incentives, changing organizational structures, and breaking down barriers. Resources across the organization should be empowered and given incentives to act in the best interest of the enterprise, not just their department.

This is not an insignificant effort in most organizations. Collaboration across the enterprise is not possible without at least one active and influential ally at the top of the organization that is able to drive change. Frequently, a grass roots effort from one department stalls out when that department is unable gain momentum and attention at the executive level.

Getting Started

So, how do you get started? I discussed the concept of analytics as a journey in a previous article . Find a project that is easy to complete and highly visible. Perhaps you start with one small initiative that is a pet project of a visible executive. It can be helpful also to find a project that bridges the gaps between two silo-ed pockets of analytic capability, since those departments are already comfortable with their own data. Leverage the entire cycle from data governance to automation so that you can set up repeatable processes. Start small, and win big, but don't lose site of the ultimate goal - developing a high performance organization built on a solid foundation of information management and advanced analytics.

The most immediate and important executive action is to start asking for proof. Force your teams to defend any recommendations with data. Find out if there are additional data sources or analytical tools that would help them to make better decisions, and make that happen. Encourage collaboration across departmental boundaries. As your success grows, you'll find your peers recognizing the momentum, and wanting to get on board themselves!

References

(1) Portions of this section were adapted from the SAS White Paper "Building an Analytics Culture: A Best Practices Guide"

Dr. Kelly McGuire is Vice President, Advanced Analytics at Wyndham Destination Networks where she leads a team of scientists and developers that build custom analytical solutions for Wyndham's vacation rental business, as well as RCI's exchange market. She is an analytics evangelist, helping hospitality and gaming businesses realize the value from big data and advanced analytics initiatives, to build a culture of fact based decision making. Her first book, "Hotel Pricing in a Social World", was recently published by Wiley books. Dr. McGuire can be contacted at 973-753-6411 or Kelly.McGuire@rci.com Extended Bio...

HotelExecutive.com retains the copyright to the articles published in the Hotel Business Review. Articles cannot be republished without prior written consent by HotelExecutive.com.

Receive our daily newsletter with the latest breaking news and hotel management best practices.
Hotel Business Review on Facebook
RESOURCE CENTER - SEARCH ARCHIVES
General Search:

DECEMBER: Hotel Law: Vast and Varied Issues and Concerns

Gregory A. Wald

On July 1, 2016 several federal agencies published regulations that significantly increased, and in some instances doubled, the civil penalties that could be levied against employers for Form I-9 paperwork violations, unauthorized employment of foreign national workers and for other immigration-related violations, including immigration discrimination charges. Due to the implementation of the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act Improvements Act of 2015 (Sec. 701 of Public Law 114-74) (“Inflation Adjustment Act”), higher fines and civil penalties have now gone into effect for assessments that occur on or after August 1, 2016. These higher penalties can be applied to violations that occurred after November 2, 2015, the day the President signed the Act into law. READ MORE

Jerome G. Grzeca

Hotels, like other U.S. companies, are struggling to find solutions to staffing shortages. Every month, more than a quarter-million Americans turn 65, which is a trend that has profound workforce and economic consequences in this country. In addition, unemployment rates continue to fall, dropping to 4.9% nationwide in September 2016. These changes, along with other factors like increases in occupancy rates and high labor costs, have resulted in many hotel companies having trouble finding and hiring qualified workers for open positions. Of course, it’s not an option for the rooms not to be cleaned or for the meals not to be prepared and served when employees are hard to find. READ MORE

Arthur Tacchino

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is likely one of the most confusing pieces of legislation you have to comply with, and the hospitality industry, especially hotels, is more complex than most when it comes to ACA reporting. This year, the stakes are higher as the IRS removes all the safety nets that were in place in 2015. Whether you reported with complete accuracy and auditability for 2015, or the notion of ACA reporting still makes your head spin, there’s a lot to learn from last year’s mishaps and this year’s expectations READ MORE

John Mavros

Employment arbitration agreements commonly include mandatory class action waivers. Class action waivers can be a powerful tool for employers to prevent potentially devastating class action lawsuits. Until several months ago, employers didn’t have to think twice about whether a class waiver was a lawful part of their arbitration agreement. That all changed when Federal Circuit Courts in Lewis v. Epic Systems (7th Circuit) and Morris v. Ernst & Young (9th Circuit) held that class action waivers violate the National Labor Relations Act’s guarantee of collective action and therefore could not be enforced under the Federal Arbitration Act. These decisions have created a circuit split between Federal courts across the country. This article will survey this treacherous legal landscape and share some guidance for employers’ arbitration agreements during these uncertain times. READ MORE

Coming Up In The January Online Hotel Business Review


Feature Focus
Mobile Technology: The Game Has Changed Forever
Consider these astounding numbers - it is forecast that in 2016 there will be 196 million smart phone users in North America alone. Worldwide the number of users is expected to surpass 2 Billion. According to hotel internet marketing firm HeBs Digital, currently more than 21% of online bookings and nearly 19% of room nights are generated from mobile devices (smart phones and tablets), while 45% of web visitors and nearly 40% of page views originate from them as well. Consumers are also increasingly using their smart phones for search queries, with more Google searches taking place on mobile devices than on computers in 10 countries, including the U.S. and Japan. Advances in mobile technology have changed the game forever and for hotels, that means having a mobile strategy is now as critical and necessary as having an Internet presence. Hotels must engage guests/travelers on their mobile devices and to add value to their experience. Mobile check-in, mobile payment options and mobile SmartKeys are quickly becoming commonplace features, as is the capacity for guests to place requests for all hotel services directly from their mobile device from anywhere on the property. In addition, some larger chains are creating their own apps which serve to enhance other facets of their operations - marketing, branding, cross-selling and impulse buying - all of which contribute to increased revenue and guest satisfaction. Still other companies are experimenting with the potential uses of wearable technology and the possibilities of geo-targeting promotions. The January Hotel Business Review will explore what some hotels are doing to maximize their opportunities in this mobile space, and will report on the solutions that are proving to be most beneficial for both companies and their guests.