Mr. Brown

Hospitality Law

Condo Hotels As Securities: Has the Litigation Boom Begun?

By Dan Brown, Partner, Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton LLP

During the past couple of years, it's been hard to miss articles in the press concerning one or more aspects of the proliferation of the "condo hotel." Those articles have generally dealt with potential issues that might arise from the new mixed property uses, the soundness and reasons for investments in condo hotels, and legal issues relating to the purchase, sale, and management of the condo hotel. One potential issue that was the subject of many articles concerning the condo hotel boom - - including an article by this author - - was whether dissatisfied condo-hotel unit owners would seek to assert claims against developers alleging that the sale of a condo hotel unit constitutes the sale of a security, thus giving rise to the right to rescind a condo unit purchase contract and seek damages, under federal and state securities laws.

Thus it is not surprising that a review of recent press reports concerning failing condo hotel projects indicates that disgruntled condo hotel owners and investors are, indeed, relying on federal and state securities laws to attempt to rescind their purchase agreements and seek damages. As such, and because the issue of whether the sale of a condo hotel unit constitutes the sale of a security has been thus far unresolved by any court, the outcomes of these first cases will be watched closely by, among others, attorneys, purchasers of condo hotels, developers, and management companies involved in condo hotels.

For example, the Wall Street Journal recently reported about a lawsuit filed in federal district court in Florida by the owners of condo hotel units at the Clearwater Cay Clubs Resort (the "Clearwater Resort") in Clearwater, Florida. In that lawsuit, the plaintiffs allege that the Clearwater Resorts' vendors and developers violated both federal and Florida state securities laws by fraudulently inducing them to invest in condo hotel units. Specifically, the plaintiffs allege that defendants promised them: (i) "substantial profits" from the investments through guaranteed income from a pool of short-term rental units; and (ii) capital appreciation due to a large scale conversion/development. Based on the allegation that the sale of a condo hotel unit constitutes a sale of a security, plaintiffs allege that the units were required to be, but were not, registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC"), and seek damages.

A similar lawsuit was filed by condo hotel unit purchasers at the Resort at Singer Island (the "Singer Island Resort") in Palm Beach, Florida. The Singer Island Resort plaintiffs allege that defendants violated federal securities law by selling the condo hotel units as investments without registering the units with the SEC. As a remedy, the plaintiffs are seeking monetary damages and the rescission of their purchase agreements.

Finally, the New York Attorney General's Office has joined the condo hotel as securities fray, recently ordering The Related Group to refund pre-construction deposits to buyers who were marketed and sold Florida condo hotel units in New York State. The directive was issued under New York State securities law.

It is still difficult to predict whether the recent lawsuits alleging federal and state securities laws violations arising from the sale of condo hotels will prove to be successful. The difficulty in answering this question is, among other things, that courts have yet to decide whether a condo hotel sale constitutes the sale of a security.

In Securities and Exchange Commission v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293, 298 (1946), the United States Supreme Court found that when, applying "economic realities," a sales contract is "a contract, transaction or scheme whereby a person invests his money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profits solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party," that contract is an "investment contract" and, therefore, a security. A condo hotel purchaser typically has the option of renting his or her unit to hotel guests, which would likely be handled through a reservation system or a rental program. Since the condo hotel unit is associated with a rental program it could potentially be deemed to be security. If deemed to be a security the sale of a condo hotel unit must be registered with the SEC and comply with the SEC's rules and regulations, including its anti-fraud provisions.

In the absence of direct judicial precedent on the issue, commentators have suggested that guidance can be found in a 1973 SEC release and 2002 no action letter. The 1973 SEC release addressed "uncertainty about whether offers of condominiums and other types of similar units may be considered to be securities" ("Condominium Release"). In the Condominium Release, the SEC found that offering securities in the form of an investment contract would arise if the condominiums were: (1) sold with emphasis on the economic benefits to the purchaser to be derived from the managerial efforts of the promoter, or a third party from rental of the units, (2) include participation in a rental pool arrangement, and (3) require the purchaser must hold his unit available for rental for any part of the year, must use an exclusive rental agent or is otherwise materially restricted in his occupancy or rental of his unit. In 2002, the SEC issued a no action to letter Intrawest Corporation, concerning the "the offer and sale of condominium units . . . coupled with an offer or agreement to perform or arrange certain rental or other services for the purchaser." The SEC stated that Intrawest's sales and rental model did not create a security because the promotion and sale of units did not emphasize any economic benefit to the purchaser derived from managerial efforts or rentals. Intrawest had represented that: (1) under no circumstances would purchasers be led to believe that they would profit from unit ownership except for property value appreciation; (2) the rental management company would only provide information in response to specific questions; (3) Intrawest's rental management program would be completely separate from the Intrawest sales program, (4) sales representatives would not receive additional compensation for unit sales tied to rental management agreements, and (5) Intrawest would not discuss the terms of any rental management agreements until a purchase and sale agreement had been executed.

If the SEC's Condominium Release and no action letter prove to be reliable guides to the law, the success of the recent lawsuits alleging violations of securities laws will depend on whether the promotion and sale of the condo hotel units emphasized any economic benefit to the purchaser derived from managerial rental efforts. If buyers, as alleged in the Clearwater Resort and Singer Island Resort lawsuits, were led to believe that the purchase of the condo hotel unit would generate guaranteed income from rental arrangements, courts may very well find that federal securities laws apply, and were violated. If securities laws apply, condo hotel developers and brokers could face serious criminal and civil liability repercussions. Moreover, it is possible that states' Attorneys General could follow the lead of the New York State Attorney General's Office and scrutinize condo hotel projects under state securities laws.

With the recent down turn in the the real estate market and investors failing to achieve their expected investment returns, the recent flurry of lawsuits alleging claims for violations of federal and state securities laws may only be the beginning of a new type of condo hotel boom.

Daniel Brown is a Partner at Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton LLP. He counsels on high stake, complex, commercial litigations and arbitrations. He has appeared in federal and state courts in New York and in other jurisdictions pro hac vice, and has argued cases before the Appellate Division, First Department, and Second Circuit Court of Appeals. Mr. Brown's casework has been reported in the New York Law Journal, New York Times, and Wall Street Journal. Mr. Brown has appeared on CNN, NBC and Court TV. He also has presented at hospitality and other Continuing Legal Education conferences. Mr. Brown can be contacted at 212-332-3879 or Extended Bio... retains the copyright to the articles published in the Hotel Business Review. Articles cannot be republished without prior written consent by

Receive our daily newsletter with the latest breaking news and hotel management best practices.
Hotel Business Review on Facebook
General Search:

APRIL: Guest Service: The Personalized Experience

Shayne Paddock

In the past year I’ve traveled to New York City on several business trips usually staying at the same hotel every time. I did that in part to learn how the hotel would interact with me on each repeat stay. Would they treat me differently? Would they recognize me on my fourth stay? Would they remember my name? Each time the reservation staff warmly greeted me but always asked “Have you stayed with us before”. Upon arriving in my room there would always be a hand written letter from the GM welcoming me to the hotel. READ MORE

Adrian Kurre

Today’s hotel guests have embraced the convenience of mobile and digital technology that facilitates everything from booking specific rooms online to checking in and using Digital Key on their smartphones. This proliferation of technology combined with excellent hospitality ensures that guests’ needs continue to be met or exceeded. At the end of the day, like we say at Hilton, we are a business of people serving people. The key is to offer guests the technological innovations they want – and some they haven’t even imagined yet – while utilizing these advances to automate basic transactions. This process allows our Team Members to focus more time on delivering exceptional experiences at every hotel to every guest. READ MORE

Robert  Habeeb

There are growing numbers of quasi-service hotels that are carving out a new niche between select-service and full-service properties. Select-service hotels have been a hot hotel industry segment for several years now. From new concepts to new developments, it has established itself as a clear front-runner in the hotel category horse race. That being said, a recent uptick in full service hotel development clearly shows that segment remains vibrant, as well. READ MORE

Gary Isenberg

By now, nearly every type of traveler prepping for a journey scans TripAdvisor for reviews of hotels in their destination city prior to securing a reservation. By perusing prior guest comments, consumers receive unfiltered and unbiased perceptions of specific properties. Travelers want to know before they book for instance if: Are the rooms clean? Is the service top-notch? Most importantly, does a hotel deliver value for the price? READ MORE

Coming Up In The May Online Hotel Business Review

Feature Focus
Eco-Friendly Practices: The Value of Sustainability
The hotel industry continues to make remarkable progress in implementing sustainability policies and procedures in their properties throughout the world. As a result, they continue to reap the benefits of increased profitability, enhanced guest experiences, and improved community relations. In addition, as industry standards are codified and adopted worldwide, hotels can now compare how their operations measure up against their competitors in terms of sustainable practices and accomplishments. This capacity to publicly compare and contrast is spurring competition and driving innovation as hotels do not wish to be left behind in this area. Water management and conservation is still a primary issue as population growth, urbanization, pollution and wasteful consumption patterns place increasing demands on freshwater supply. Water recycling; installing low-flow fixtures; using digital sensors to control water usage; and even harvesting rainwater are just a few things that some hotels are doing to preserve this precious resource. Waste management is another major concern. Through policies of reduce, reuse and recycle, some hotels are implementing “zero-waste” programs with the goal of substantially reducing their landfill waste which produces carbon dioxide and methane gases. Other hotels have established comprehensive training programs that reinforce the value of sustainability. There is employee engagement through posters and quizzes, and even contests are held to increase innovation, sensitivity and environmental awareness. Some hotels are also monitoring a guest’s energy usage and rewarding those who consumed less energy with gifts and incentives. The May issue of the Hotel Business Review will document how some hotels are integrating eco-friendly practices into their operations and how they and the environment are benefiting from them.